Engaging Patients in Research That Involves Meditation: Religious Concerns and Nursing Implications
In Plain Language: cancer pain, explained
Studies evaluating the use of meditative practices for supporting symptom management among patients undergoing cancer treatment have increased substantially in recent years. Although meditative practices as adjuncts to promoting health have become mainstream, concerns that such strategies conflict with traditional religious tenets have co-occurred. In the context of a 12-week sequential multiple assignment randomized trial of home-based meditative practices and reflexology delivered to patients with cancer by or with family caregivers to manage symptoms, early attrition was identified in the meditative practices arm. Finding religious concerns were factors contributing to attrition; the purpose is to describe adjustments to the training protocol for study recruiters and interveners when enrolling participants and teaching patient-caregiver dyads meditative practices. The training protocol for recruiters and interveners was adapted to address religious concerns related to meditative practices. Since initiation, recruiters and interveners have appreciated the adapted protocol, which has improved their capacity to respond to religious concerns. Participants have responded well to consideration of the practices as mindful movements coordinated with breath. Given broader application of meditation in symptom management studies, researchers will need to be ready to address religious concerns. It is essential that protocols for introducing meditation are broadly presented to respond to concerns of patients and cancer caregivers regarding perceived conflicts with their specific religious beliefs. As the provision of integrative care options that include meditation training for patients grows, nurses require awareness of potential barriers and strategies to ameliorate religious concerns.
Key Findings: what this pilot study found about cancer pain
- ✓Religious concerns about meditative practices were identified as a significant factor contributing to early attrition in the meditative practices arm of a cancer symptom management trial.
- ✓Training protocols for study recruiters and interveners were adapted to address religious objections when enrolling participants and teaching patient-caregiver dyads meditative practices.
- ✓Meditative practices used as adjuncts for cancer symptom management can conflict with patients' traditional religious tenets, requiring culturally sensitive recruitment and intervention strategies.
What This Means for You
If you have religious concerns about meditation, consider asking your practitioner to frame it as mindful breathing and movement rather than a spiritual practice, as this approach has helped other patients feel more comfortable.
What This Means for Practitioners
Being prepared to address religious concerns and reframe meditative practices as secular mindful movement can significantly improve patient engagement and reduce dropout from symptom management programs.
Cancer pain: common questions
What does this study say about cancer pain?
If you have religious concerns about meditation, consider asking your practitioner to frame it as mindful breathing and movement rather than a spiritual practice, as this approach has helped other patients feel more comfortable.
What did this study find?
Religious concerns about meditative practices were identified as a significant factor contributing to early attrition in the meditative practices arm of a cancer symptom management trial. Training protocols for study recruiters and interveners were adapted to address religious objections when enrolling participants and teaching patient-caregiver dyads meditative practices. Meditative practices used as adjuncts for cancer symptom management can conflict with patients' traditional religious tenets, requiring culturally sensitive recruitment and intervention strategies.
How strong is this evidence?
This is a pilot study and we rate its evidence preliminary. It was published in Cancer nursing, a Q1 journal. This study is indexed here for context; it did not test reflexology itself.
Related Research
Complementary therapy in practice
Improving Quality of Life in The Constipated Older Person: Reflexology or Abdominal Massage? A Two-Group, Randomized Comparative Trial
Mind-Body Interventions for People With Cancer: Evidence, Innovation, and Implementation
Therapeutic Massage for Cancer Survivors: An Umbrella Review
A Service Evaluation of Heisei Shiatsu Massage as an Adjunct to the Pharmacological Management of Cancer Pain
Looking for a reflexologist?
Find practitioners who can help with the conditions studied in this research.
Find a Reflexologist