Skip to main content

Using SMART design to improve symptom management among cancer patients: A study protocol

Authors: Sikorskii Alla, Wyatt Gwen, Lehto Rebecca, Victorson David, Badger Terry, Pace ThaddeusJournal: Research in nursing & healthPublished: December 1, 2017DOI: 10.1002/nur.21836
Preliminary EvidencePilot

In Plain Language: cancer pain, explained

In this in-progress sequential multiple assignment randomized trial (SMART), dyads of solid tumor cancer patients and their caregivers are initially randomized to 4 weeks of reflexology or meditative (mindfulness) practices provided by/with their caregiver in the patient's home or to a control group. After 4 weeks, intervention group dyads in which patients do not show improvement in fatigue (non-responders) are re-randomized to either receive additional time with the same therapy during weeks 5-8 or to add the other therapy. The aims are (1) to compare reflexology and meditative practices groups during weeks 1-4 on patients' fatigue severity, summed symptom inventory score, depressive symptoms, and anxiety, so as to determine the relative effectiveness of these therapies and the characteristics of responders and non-responders to each therapy. (2) Among reflexology non-responders based on fatigue score at week 4, to determine patient symptom outcomes when meditative practices are added during weeks 5-8, versus continuing with reflexology alone. (3) Among meditative practices non-responders based on fatigue score at week 4, to determine patient symptom outcomes when reflexology is added during weeks 5-8, versus continuing with meditative practices alone. (4) To compare improvements in patient symptom outcomes among the three groups created by the first randomization. (5) To explore which dyadic characteristics are associated with optimal patient symptom outcomes, to determine tailoring variables for decision rules of future interventions. The trial has a target of 331 dyads post-attrition and has 150 dyads enrolled. We are overcoming challenges with dyadic recruitment and retention while maintaining fidelity.

Key Findings: what this pilot study found about cancer pain

  • ✓This SMART design study evaluates reflexology and mindfulness-based meditative practices delivered by caregivers in the home setting for managing fatigue and other symptoms in cancer patients over an 8-week period.
  • ✓The study uses a re-randomization approach where patients who do not improve in fatigue after 4 weeks of initial therapy are assigned to either continue the same therapy with increased duration or switch to the alternative therapy.
  • ✓Primary outcomes measured include fatigue severity, summed symptom inventory scores, depressive symptoms, and anxiety, with analysis focusing on determining which patients respond best to reflexology versus meditative practices.

What This Means for You

This is an early-stage study still being conducted, so we don't yet have results showing whether reflexology helps cancer-related fatigue, but researchers are actively testing it.

What This Means for Practitioners

This SMART design study protocol offers a framework for identifying which patients respond best to reflexology alone versus when combining it with other therapies may be more effective.

Read Full Paper↗

Cancer pain: common questions

What does this study say about cancer pain?

This is an early-stage study still being conducted, so we don't yet have results showing whether reflexology helps cancer-related fatigue, but researchers are actively testing it.

What did this study find?

This SMART design study evaluates reflexology and mindfulness-based meditative practices delivered by caregivers in the home setting for managing fatigue and other symptoms in cancer patients over an 8-week period. The study uses a re-randomization approach where patients who do not improve in fatigue after 4 weeks of initial therapy are assigned to either continue the same therapy with increased duration or switch to the alternative therapy. Primary outcomes measured include fatigue severity, summed symptom inventory scores, depressive symptoms, and anxiety, with analysis focusing on determining which patients respond best to reflexology versus meditative practices.

How strong is this evidence?

This is a pilot study and we rate its evidence preliminary. It was published in Research in nursing & health. This study is indexed here for context; it did not test reflexology itself.

Related Research

Looking for a reflexologist?

Find practitioners who can help with the conditions studied in this research.

Find a Reflexologist